Some spoilers observe for anybody who is not present with the Strolling Lifeless TV present and comedian collection.
Anytime a guide or comedian guide will get tailored as one other type of media, followers are going to make countless comparisons. That goes for enormous fantasy epics like Sport of Thrones to kid-focused adventures like Captain Underpants. However I believe most would agree that The Strolling Lifeless earns as many adaptation comparisons as anything on the market, and we’re at all times eager to dive into those conversations.
Right here, we have rounded up all of the Strolling Lifeless characters whose comedian guide iterations are extra pleasant than the live-action variations. In some circumstances, the disparity is minimal, whereas in others, the unique characters are worlds higher than the TV characters. Let’s begin off with one in all AMC hit’s most irritating characters, whatever the supply materials.
In The Comics: As one of many comedian guide’s most iconic characters, Andrea was a pillar of power, confidence, and firearm abilities, and she or he additionally delivered as a lot emotional thrust as anybody else within the collection. Every relationship she entered into was extremely significant, from her closeness with Dale to the surrogate motherhood that she took on with Ben, Billy and (later) Carl to her ultimately settling down with Rick. And Andrea’s dying was most likely as heartbreaking as another dying from the comics.
In The TV Present: Laurie Holden was a superb option to tackle the position of Andrea, and the character initially appeared like she’d stay pretty near the unique model. However no, that each one fell aside earlier than too lengthy, and one of many worst choices in Strolling Lifeless historical past concerned Andrea shifting to Woodbury to start out a romantic relationship with The Governor, a dipshit transfer that sealed the more and more insufferable character’s destiny. Even Holden herself wasn’t fond of how that story turned out.
In The Comics: By the character of his lethal crimes, his vulgar speech and his tyrannical nature, Negan ought to have been the collection’ least likable character, and but the ruthless villain stays one in all The Strolling Lifeless‘s greatest fan favorites. His fixed swearing has at all times been extra hilarious than intimidating, and he is solely turn into extra fascinating and nuanced as time has passed by, with the standalone offshoot Here is Negan providing a backstory that, whereas generally superfluous, expanded upon Negan’s blink-and-you’ll-miss-it emotional core. He is as colourful and dynamic a villain as one may get in black-and-white.
In The TV Present: Jeffrey Dean Morgan had quite a bit to reside as much as when taking up the live-action iteration of Negan, and there is no denying the scary charisma he exudes in each scene he is in. However there was at all times going to be one thing misplaced in translation when bringing Negan into the TV present, together with his ghoulish comedian guide acts turning into all of the extra monstrous and uncomfortable once they’re not illustrated. Plus, the present appears to haven’t any clue easy methods to make the most of Negan correctly, bouncing between ignoring him fully after which giving him all the main focus. Morgan will at all times be nice, however Comedian Negan will at all times be that a lot larger as compared.